Self-Directed IRAs for High-Net-Worth Individuals
Looking for a trusted network of high-net-worth peers? Apply now to join Long Angle, a vetted community of high-net-worth investors, entrepreneurs, and professionals. Access confidential discussions, live events, peer groups, and private market deals.
Table of Contents
Is a Self-Directed IRA Worth It?
Self-Directed IRA Rules
Self-Directed IRA Roth vs. Traditional
How to Open a Self-Directed IRA
Self-Directed IRA Investment Options
Common SDIRA Challenges
Strategies for Optimizing Self-Directed IRAs
Are Self-Directed IRAs the Right Choice?
Self-directed IRAs (SDIRAs) have been gaining attention in the financial community, particularly for investors seeking more control over their retirement assets. These accounts provide the flexibility to invest in assets beyond the standard offerings of stocks, bonds, and mutual funds—ranging from real estate to private equity. SDIRAs are a valuable tool for high-net-worth individuals looking to expand their financial portfolios in innovative ways.
Still, self-directed IRAs are not for everyone, and they come with certain challenges. Investors should carefully consider the pros and cons before committing to a SDIRA.
Is a Self-Directed IRA Worth It?
A good rule of thumb is that a self-directed IRA is only recommended if the account balance exceeds $100,000. The benefits of control and flexibility in an SDIRA come with administrative costs and complexities that may not justify smaller portfolios. The expenses of maintaining the account and the paperwork involved can erode the returns of more modest portfolios.
When selecting an SDIRA provider, consider options like Forge Trust, known for user-friendly Roth SDIRA services, or IRA Financial Group, which offers cost-effective structures (around $175/year with multi-account discounts as of 2023). These providers specialize in alternative investments and offer robust customer support to help navigate the complexities of SDIRAs.
Setting up an SDIRA can also be daunting, especially for those unfamiliar with the paperwork and IRS rules. It is crucial to work with custodians who are reliable and offer excellent customer support to navigate these complexities smoothly.
Self-Directed IRA Rules
SDIRAs come with specific rules that must be followed closely to avoid penalties and disqualification of the account.
First, all investments must be made through a custodian that specializes in self-directed accounts. The custodian does not offer investment advice but facilitates transactions on behalf of the account holder. Second, the IRS prohibits certain types of investments, including collectibles like art, antiques, and alcoholic beverages. In addition, the IRS has strict rules about prohibited transactions and disqualified persons. Account holders cannot personally benefit from the investments in the IRA, and certain transactions with close family members (e.g., parents, children, or spouses) are not allowed. For example, an investor cannot purchase a property using SDIRA funds and then rent it to a family member.
It is crucial to maintain detailed records of all transactions and stay informed of the legal requirements to avoid triggering tax penalties or disqualification.
SDIRA contributions are limited to a certain amount per year. In 2024, the annual limit was $7,000. Those who are 50 or older have the option to submit catch-up contributions of up to $1,000 on top of the annual contribution cap. For self-employed individuals, a Solo 401(k) can be used for even larger contributions through Mega Backdoor Roth strategies, allowing up to $69,000 in annual contributions ($76,500 for those 50 and older).
Withdrawals before the age of 59 ½ are subject to both income tax and a 10% penalty.
Self-Directed IRA Roth vs. Traditional
When selecting a self-directed IRA, individuals must choose between a traditional SDIRA and a Roth SDIRA, each of which has distinct tax advantages. In a traditional SDIRA, contributions are tax-deductible, meaning that the investor's taxable income is reduced by the amount contributed. However, the funds will be taxed upon withdrawal in retirement, which may be less favorable for those in a higher tax bracket.
In contrast, Roth SDIRA contributions are made with after-tax dollars. While this means there is no immediate tax benefit, withdrawals in retirement are entirely tax-free, provided certain conditions are met. For those who can afford to pay taxes upfront, a Roth SDIRA may provide significant long-term benefits, especially when investments have decades to grow.
The decision between traditional and Roth SDIRAs depends on several factors, including current tax rates, future tax expectations, and personal financial goals. Many high-net-worth individuals find Roth SDIRAs particularly appealing due to the opportunity for tax-free growth and withdrawals.
High-Net-Worth Income & Spending Report
Long Angle's annual High-Net-Worth Income and Spending report analyzes income sources, expenses, savings strategies, and spending behaviors of high-net-worth households.
How to Open a Self-Directed IRA
While opening a self-directed IRA is a straightforward process, it requires careful planning and the selection of the right custodian. The first step is to identify a custodian or trustee who specializes in self-directed accounts. Not all financial institutions offer SDIRAs, so it is important to choose a custodian that understands the complexities of alternative investments and IRS regulations.
Once a custodian has been chosen, the individual completes the necessary paperwork to establish the account, similar to opening a traditional or Roth IRA. It is also necessary to fund the account through contributions, transfers, or rollovers from an existing IRA or 401(k). After the account is funded, the individual can begin selecting and managing the investments, which the custodian will execute on behalf of the account holder.
For those seeking more direct control over their investments, especially for real estate transactions, a checkbook IRA structure can be beneficial. In this setup, the SDIRA owns an LLC, allowing the account holder to manage investments more directly, including writing checks for expenses. However, this structure requires careful setup and management to ensure compliance with IRS regulations.
Self-Directed IRA Investment Options
Real Estate
Real estate is a popular investment for SDIRA holders. For example, focusing on private money lending to real estate developers via secured promissory notes can yield double-digit returns and provide relatively passive income while mitigating some of the risks inherent in real estate ownership.
However, direct ownership of rental properties within an SDIRA presents certain challenges. First, tax benefits like depreciation and mortgage interest deductions are not available. Furthermore, all income generated by the property must remain within the IRA and cannot be used for personal expenses without incurring penalties.
Real estate flips can be another strong investment within an SDIRA, especially when managed through an agent or checkbook IRA. With a checkbook IRA, the SDIRA owns an LLC, allowing for more direct control over the investment process, including writing checks to contractors. However, IRS rules about self-dealing must be observed to avoid penalties, and any profits must remain within the SDIRA.
As of 2024, the IRS has increased scrutiny on SDIRAs, particularly regarding prohibited transactions and valuation of alternative assets like real estate. Investors should stay informed about current regulations and work closely with their custodians to ensure compliance.
Angel Investing
SDIRA investors can also consider allocating a portion of their funds to angel investing. Peter Thiel famously turned his Roth IRA into a fortune through early-stage startup investments, and it is possible to achieve large gains through angel investing. The tax advantages of a Roth SDIRA make this approach particularly attractive, as any gains from successful investments can grow tax-free.
However, keep in mind that angel investing carries significant risk and, due to the illiquid nature of startups, these investments often take years to mature. Patience and a long-term view are essential for success in this asset class.
When engaging in angel investing through an SDIRA, it is important to seek out startups with strong growth potential and to manage risk by diversifying across multiple investments.
Alternative Investments
As the financial landscape continues to evolve, more investors are turning to alternative assets to diversify their portfolios. Self-directed IRAs provide a unique opportunity to invest in these less conventional assets, from real estate and private equity to venture capital and cryptocurrency.
Common SDIRA Challenges
Here are some common mistakes that can prevent investors from achieving success with self-directed IRAs:
Overcomplicating Investments
While investing in unconventional assets is appealing, the complexity of managing these investments should not overshadow their benefits. For instance, directly owning rental properties in an SDIRA can be cumbersome, and the loss of tax advantages may outweigh the potential gains.
Not Adhering to IRS Rules
When investing in SDIRAs, it is essential to maintain compliance with IRS regulations, particularly regarding prohibited transactions. For example, an individual cannot personally benefit from assets held within the SDIRA, such as by using a vacation home owned by the account. Violations can lead to severe penalties, so a solid understanding of these rules is essential.
Administrative Hurdles
SDIRA investing does require a larger administrative burden compared to other options. Unlike traditional IRAs, where the custodian manages most tasks, self-directed accounts require much more involvement from the account holder. This includes handling paperwork, maintaining compliance with IRS rules, and managing investments.
Whether related to custodian fees or legal costs for setting up a checkbook IRA, administrative expenses can accumulate and erode returns. Investors should always consider these costs when calculating potential profitability.
Capital calls, common in real estate and private equity, can be particularly challenging within an SDIRA. Each time funds need to be transferred, custodian approval is required, which can be a slow and frustrating process. To minimize the number of transactions and administrative hassle, opt for more straightforward investments with long-term holds, such as promissory notes.
For investments involving frequent transactions, such as real estate flips, a checkbook IRA may offer a more efficient solution. This structure provides direct control over funds and can expedite transactions. However, setting up the necessary legal framework, including an LLC, can be complex and should be approached with a thorough understanding of the requirements.
Strategies for Optimizing Self-Directed IRAs
Establishing custodial accounts for minors is a strategy that allows families to build generational wealth in a tax-advantaged manner. Setting up such accounts early on can lay the foundation for long-term financial security for future generations.
Another innovative strategy involves using a Solo 401k for larger contributions through Mega Backdoor Roths. For self-employed individuals, this can significantly increase retirement savings compared to traditional IRAs or 401(k)s.
Ongoing education and community support are crucial for successful SDIRA management. Consider attending workshops on advanced SDIRA strategies, networking with experienced SDIRA investors, and utilizing shared resources like LLC operating agreement templates.
Are Self-Directed IRAs the Right Choice?
Self-directed IRAs offer investors the chance to diversify their retirement portfolios with a wide range of assets. From real estate and angel investing to more unconventional opportunities, these accounts provide greater flexibility and control over retirement funds. However, they come with increased administrative complexity, costs, and the risk of running afoul of IRS rules.
It is best to view an SDIRA as part of a broader diversification strategy. High-net-worth individuals can combine SDIRAs with other retirement accounts to create a well-rounded portfolio that balances traditional and alternative investments. For example, an investor might use their SDIRA for real estate and angel investments while maintaining a traditional IRA for more conventional assets like stocks and bonds.
Investors considering an SDIRA should carefully evaluate their financial situation, long-term investment goals, and willingness to manage the additional administrative burden. For those willing to navigate these challenges, self-directed IRAs can serve as a powerful tool for building a diversified, tax-advantaged retirement portfolio.
To illustrate how a high-net-worth individual might leverage an SDIRA, consider this example:
An investor with a $500,000 SDIRA could diversify their portfolio as follows:
40% in private money lending for real estate through secured promissory notes, aiming for double-digit returns
30% in a carefully selected portfolio of angel investments in early-stage startups
20% in a private equity fund focusing on mid-market companies
10% in cryptocurrency for exposure to digital assets
This diversification strategy balances potential high returns with risk spread across different asset classes. The investor might use a checkbook IRA structure for efficient management of real estate investments, while working closely with their custodian on other investments to ensure compliance.
Remember, this is just one possible approach. Your SDIRA strategy should be tailored to your individual financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment expertise. Always consult with financial and legal professionals when structuring your SDIRA investments.
A community of high-net-worth individuals such as the one at Long Angle provides an avenue to discuss investing (and a wide range of other topics) with like-minded peers. Members also unlock access to curated alternative investments, exclusive events, and focused peer advisory groups. Join Long Angle to learn more.
Looking to expand your investment network?
Join Long Angle, a private community of high-net-worth investors. Together, we leverage our collective expertise and assets to access, diligence, and underwrite institutional-quality alternative investments.
