Oil and Gas Investing: Outlook, Benefits, and Best Practices
Looking for a trusted network of high-net-worth peers? Apply now to join Long Angle, a vetted community of high-net-worth investors, entrepreneurs, and professionals. Access confidential discussions, live events, peer groups, and private market deals.
Table of Contents
Types of Oil and Gas Investment Opportunities
Oil and Gas Investment Tax Benefits
Oil and Gas Investing Risks
Financial and Operational Considerations
Oil and Gas Investing Best Practices
Long-Term Outlook of the Oil and Gas Industry
Is Oil and Gas a Good Investment?
Oil and gas investing is a popular, albeit complex, strategy for high-net-worth investors aiming to diversify their portfolios, benefit from tax incentives, and potentially achieve attractive returns. In 2023, the U.S. produced more oil than any country in history, largely due to the rise of horizontal fracking, and the industry continues to hold strong.
However, the oil and gas industry also presents unique risks and requires careful scrutiny. This article explores oil and gas investments, tax implications, and best practices to maximize benefits and minimize risks.
Types of Oil and Gas Investment Opportunities
Oil and gas investments offer various entry points, each with distinct risk profiles, financial structures, and tax incentives. Among the most prominent options are mineral rights, drilling partnerships, and Master Limited Partnerships (MLPs).
Mineral rights typically offer a lower-risk profile compared to direct drilling investments, as they involve ownership of the land where drilling occurs, generating royalties from production without direct operational costs or liability. Conversely, drilling partnerships are high-stakes endeavors with the potential for significant tax advantages because they allow deductions for intangible drilling costs (IDCs) and depletion allowances. MLPs, on the other hand, provide a publicly traded, income-generating opportunity with tax-efficient distributions, but they also expose investors to oil price volatility and market-driven performance.
Private oil and gas investment funds offer another layer of diversification, providing investors with access to a professionally managed oil and gas portfolio. Some funds focus on mineral rights, offering a steady income stream from royalty payments, while others focus on exploration and production (E&P), offering the potential for capital gains.
Each type of investment carries unique advantages and risks, and the choice of vehicle depends on an investor's financial goals and risk tolerance.
Oil and Gas Investment Tax Benefits
One of the most attractive aspects of oil and gas investments is their tax benefits, particularly for high-net-worth individuals looking to offset W-2 income. For those investing in drilling partnerships as a General Partner (GP), the IRS allows substantial deductions for IDCs, which can sometimes represent up to 90% of the initial investment in the first year. However, this benefit comes with the responsibility of “active” participation; investors assume liability for any operational mishaps. Therefore, such tax benefits are primarily designed to encourage domestic energy production by providing incentives that compensate for the high risks involved.
Mineral rights investments also offer tax advantages through depletion allowances, which effectively reduce taxable income by acknowledging the declining production capacity of an oil or gas well over time.
In contrast, MLPs and similar structures offer tax-efficient income distributions, as they are pass-through entities. However, tax complexity can arise with MLPs, especially for investors unfamiliar with Schedule K-1 forms, which report an investor’s share of income, deductions, and credits.
Oil and Gas Investing Risks
Investing in oil and gas requires heightened due diligence compared to traditional asset classes. It is particularly important to select a reputable sponsor with a proven track record. Investors are advised to look for sponsors with experience managing multiple cycles of oil price volatility and a solid understanding of market dynamics. This scrutiny is especially important when considering drilling projects, where the quality of the operator can dramatically impact investment outcomes. Seasoned investors recommend obtaining a complete history of a sponsor’s portfolio performance and prioritizing sponsors with extensive experience in conservative underwriting and well management.
Geographic location also plays a significant role in investment success. Regions such as the Permian Basin in Texas are well regarded due to their long-established production history and favorable regulatory environment. Less established regions may offer lower upfront costs but can carry higher risks due to infrastructure limitations and geological uncertainty.
Investors should also be wary of overpromoted investments, particularly those marketed primarily for their tax benefits. The general rule of thumb is that if a deal seems too focused on tax deductions without a strong investment thesis, it may lack the fundamentals to deliver sustainable returns. Sponsors sometimes inflate intangible costs to increase tax deductions, masking the underlying risk that a well may not be productive or that returns may not meet expectations. Investors should cross-reference reported costs and predicted returns carefully.
High-Net-Worth Income & Spending Report
Long Angle's annual High-Net-Worth Income and Spending report analyzes income sources, expenses, savings strategies, and spending behaviors of high-net-worth households.
Financial and Operational Considerations
The oil and gas industry is heavily capital-intensive, with significant costs associated with drilling, production, and environmental compliance. Investors in drilling partnerships need to be prepared for an exponential decline in production rates after the initial years. A well's output is typically front-loaded, producing around 50% of its lifetime output within the first few years. If the expected cash flow does not allow for a return of principal within this period, the investment may fail to meet its objectives. Furthermore, drilling projects are non-collateralized, meaning that once funds are committed, they are entirely at risk, unlike in real estate, where physical assets can be sold or repurposed.
Environmental liability can be another operational risk, as drilling activities are inherently prone to hazards like oil spills or blowouts. The level of liability can be substantial, especially for investors classified as General Partners, who bear a share of the project’s risks and legal responsibilities. For high-net-worth investors, it is crucial to assess the sponsor’s insurance coverage and risk mitigation measures, including safety protocols and environmental compliance. Sponsors who cut corners in these areas not only expose themselves but also their investors to potentially catastrophic liabilities.
Without sufficient due diligence, there is the potential for significant losses despite the initial tax incentives. Steer away from smaller syndications and operators with limited experience, which can often lead to financial losses or even cases of fraud.
Oil and Gas Investing Best Practices
To navigate the complexities of oil and gas investing, investors should work closely with tax professionals who are well-versed in oil and gas taxation to maximize allowable deductions and understand the implications of active versus passive income. Consulting with a financial advisor who specializes in oil and gas is particularly valuable for structuring the investment and handling the intricate tax reporting requirements.
As with any investment, investors should engage in thorough due diligence on any potential sponsor or operator. Key factors include examining the sponsor’s past performance, scrutinizing their underwriting assumptions, and reviewing any internal engineering reports. It is equally important to verify the financial health and operational track record of the sponsor, particularly in terms of how they have navigated previous downturns in oil prices.
High-net-worth investors should also consider prioritizing income-generating assets like mineral rights or royalties over direct drilling investments. Although drilling partnerships may provide higher returns if successful, the associated risks and liabilities make them suitable only for those with a high tolerance for potential losses. For those seeking a more balanced approach, MLPs and publicly traded oil and gas stocks offer exposure to the energy sector with reduced operational involvement and regulatory risk.
One successful approach is to invest in larger, reputable funds managed by well-established sponsors. These funds may not offer the same aggressive tax benefits as smaller partnerships, but they provide greater security, a diversified portfolio of assets, and professional oversight. For instance, some investors opt for mineral rights funds managed by large public firms that undergo regular audits and offer more transparent financial reporting.
High-net-worth investors may also find it beneficial to diversify within the oil and gas sector by combining mineral rights investments with more liquid options like energy-focused ETFs or MLPs. This approach allows for income generation, potential capital appreciation, and tax efficiency without exposing a disproportionate share of the portfolio to the risks inherent in direct drilling projects.
Long-Term Outlook of the Oil and Gas Industry
According to the International Energy Forum, annual upstream oil and gas capital expenditures are set to grow by $135 billion by 2030, reaching a substantial $738 billion and reflecting a 41% increase from two years ago. Despite the anticipated plateau in demand, a cumulative $4.3 trillion is still expected to be needed between 2025 and 2030 to stabilize supply. A significant portion of this capital is directed toward North and Latin America, which together are driving over 60% of upstream capex growth. Latin America, in particular, is expected to contribute robustly to conventional crude supply, with countries like Brazil and Guyana spearheading this growth.
The recent uptick in capital inflows has mitigated immediate risks of underinvestment in the sector. Factors such as elevated prices, resilient production from traditionally volatile regions, and a restored spare production capacity have helped maintain a stable supply outlook. However, potential shifts in commodity prices, geopolitical factors, or environmental policies could resurface concerns of underinvestment. This backdrop, combined with the demand variability tied to the global energy transition, means investors may need to prepare for a dynamic market landscape.
For high-net-worth investors, maintaining a long-term view when investing in oil and gas may offer resilient returns, provided they carefully navigate the sector’s evolving regulatory and geopolitical complexities.
It is important to note that some individuals have moral concerns surrounding the oil and gas industry due to potential environmental impacts. Individuals participating in impact investing, therefore, may choose to invest elsewhere, regardless of the return potential.
Is Oil and Gas a Good Investment?
Investing in oil and gas can offer substantial tax benefits, consistent income, and strong returns for high-net-worth individuals seeking to diversify their portfolios. However, these benefits are tempered by high risk, and navigating the sector requires a nuanced understanding of tax regulations, operational complexities, and market cycles.
By conducting rigorous due diligence, focusing on reputable sponsors, and considering tax incentives, high-net-worth investors can make informed decisions in oil and gas investments.
Looking for a community to discuss investment opportunities? Long Angle brings together a diverse group of high-net-worth individuals for open discussions on everything from alternative investments to parenting advice to travel recommendations. Members can also participate in events, peer groups, and exclusive investment opportunities. Apply today to get started.
Looking to expand your investment network?
Join Long Angle, a private community of high-net-worth investors. Together, we leverage our collective expertise and assets to access, diligence, and underwrite institutional-quality alternative investments.
