How to Invest in Gold: Physical, ETF, and Mining Stock Allocation Strategies
Looking for a trusted network of high-net-worth peers? Apply now to join Long Angle, a vetted community of high-net-worth investors, entrepreneurs, and professionals. Access confidential discussions, live events, peer groups, and private market deals.
Table of Contents
The Value of Gold in a High-Net-Worth Portfolio
Investment Options in Gold
How to Invest in Gold
Diversifying Gold Investments
Gold as a Strategic Asset for High-Net-Worth Investors
For high-net-worth investors considering how to invest in gold, the question often revolves around which investment form aligns best with their wealth strategy. From physical gold coins to exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and mining stocks, each choice brings its own set of advantages, limitations, and strategic implications.
Investors exploring these options need a clear understanding of the market dynamics, liquidity concerns, and potential tax implications that come with allocations in gold.
The Value of Gold in a High-Net-Worth Portfolio
Gold holds a unique place in wealth management due to its dual role as an inflation hedge and a perceived store of value in times of financial crisis. Unlike other assets, gold’s value remains steady even during periods of economic uncertainty, making it a welcome addition for investors seeking portfolio diversification. Historic performance reflects this, as gold has often shown a negative correlation with equities, particularly during market downturns.
That said, gold may not deliver substantial returns when viewed as a growth investment. Instead, gold can act as a stabilizing asset that preserves wealth when other segments of the portfolio are underperforming. When held in conjunction with traditional assets, it can add “ballast” to a portfolio, reducing volatility and supporting wealth preservation long-term.
Recent market dynamics have underscored gold's role in wealth preservation, with prices reaching record highs above $2,300 per ounce in 2024. This appreciation reflects increasing institutional adoption, notably from central banks, and growing interest in de-dollarization strategies among global investors.
Investment Options in Gold
There are several ways to invest in gold, each suited to different financial objectives and risk tolerances. High-net-worth individuals may find that a blended approach, combining physical holdings with paper assets, offers the best balance between liquidity and security.
Physical Gold: Coins and Bullion
Holding physical gold, such as coins and bullion, provides the reassurance of owning a tangible asset outside of the financial system. For investors considering gold as a “collapse hedge” or as an insurance policy against systemic risk, physical gold may be a good choice. It eliminates counterparty risk, a concern in scenarios where the financial system itself may be compromised.
Popular options for investing in physical gold include coins like the American Eagle, Canadian Maple Leaf, and South African Krugerrand. These coins are globally recognized and easy to trade, providing liquidity within the realm of physical assets. Platforms such as JM Bullion and APMEX offer access to these coins with competitive premiums over spot prices.
However, holding physical gold also comes with specific challenges. Transaction costs can be higher compared to those for paper gold, and storage incurs additional expenses, especially if professional vaulting services are used. While some investors choose to store gold themselves, this approach introduces physical security risks. Others opt to store their holdings in offshore vaults, such as in Singapore, where companies like Silver Bullion offer insured storage for investors looking to add an extra layer of security.
International storage solutions are gaining popularity among high-net-worth investors seeking jurisdictional diversification. Beyond Singapore, Dubai has emerged as a competitive market for physical gold purchases, often offering favorable pricing compared to Western markets.
Gold Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs)
Investors seeking simplicity and liquidity often turn to gold ETFs. ETFs like the SPDR Gold Shares (GLD) and GraniteShares Gold Trust (BAR) hold physical gold in vaults and trade like stocks on major exchanges, allowing investors to gain exposure to gold without dealing with physical storage. They also come with low fees compared to holding physical gold, particularly when managing larger sums.
Historical data shows gold ETFs have delivered approximately 400% returns over a 30-year period, though typically underperforming the S&P 500. However, their value proposition lies primarily in portfolio stabilization rather than pure returns.
However, investors should carefully consider the differences between gold ETF offerings. For example, GLD, one of the most established gold ETFs, has a 0.40% expense ratio but benefits from high liquidity, making it suitable for short-term trading. By contrast, GLDM—often referred to as the “mini” version of GLD—represents a smaller quantity of gold per share and has a 0.10% expense ratio, making it a cost-effective option for long-term investors. This difference allows investors to select a vehicle that aligns with their investment horizon and cost sensitivity.
It is important to note that while ETFs offer exposure to gold’s price movements, they may not fulfill the same purpose as physical gold in the event of a severe financial crisis. In a total collapse scenario, ETF shares may lack the inherent security of tangible gold, so for those viewing gold as a financial safeguard, ETFs may not provide the necessary peace of mind.
Gold Mining Stocks
An often-overlooked way to invest in gold is through gold mining companies. These gold investment stocks give investors exposure to both gold prices and the operational potential of the company. Mining stocks can offer substantial returns when gold prices are high, especially if the company has efficient production and a healthy balance sheet. Additionally, mining stocks are subject to capital gains taxes rather than the higher collectibles tax rate that applies to physical gold and gold ETFs, presenting a tax-efficient option for investors.
Gold mining indices, which aggregate a selection of gold investment companies, offer diversification within the mining sector and can reduce the risks associated with any single company. Over certain time frames, gold mining indices have outperformed gold ETFs, adding the potential for higher returns, albeit with increased volatility.
However, investing in mining stocks introduces risks that are not directly tied to the price of gold itself. Corporate performance, geopolitical factors, and production costs all influence the valuation of mining stocks. Investors who choose mining stocks must weigh these factors and consider their tolerance for the additional risks involved.
Currency Market Exposure
Some institutional investors gain gold exposure through XAUUSD spot trading, which offers high liquidity and potential leverage opportunities. While this approach requires sophisticated market understanding, it can provide efficient tactical positioning for larger portfolios.
How to Invest in Gold
For high-net-worth investors, the ideal gold investing strategy may involve combining multiple investment types. Before proceeding, it is essential to consider the underlying rationale for gold investing and the factors that may influence its performance within a broader portfolio. As with any risky investment, consulting with a wealth management firm or financial advisor may be wise.
Establishing Investment Goals
The first step when incorporating gold into a portfolio is understanding its intended role. For investors viewing gold primarily as an inflation hedge, non-physical options such as ETFs or mining stocks may be preferable due to their liquidity and cost-effectiveness. In contrast, those who see gold as a form of wealth insurance may favor physical gold, valuing its independence from financial markets and systems.
A clear objective helps shape one’s investment strategy and informs decisions about asset type, holding structure, and allocation size. Investors with varying goals may opt to divide investments between physical and non-physical assets, ensuring both security and liquidity.
Tax Implications
Physical gold and ETFs are taxed as collectibles in the United States, with long-term capital gains taxed at 28%. In contrast, mining stocks are subject to standard capital gains tax rates, which can provide a tax advantage for investors seeking growth potential. Those with larger estates may also benefit from structuring gold holdings in trusts or other estate planning vehicles to minimize transfer tax liabilities.
Costs and Fees
Investors should assess the costs associated with each type of gold investment. Physical gold requires premium payments above the spot price, and storage costs add to the overall expense. ETFs and mining stocks generally come with lower fees, making them more economical for certain investors. However, management fees, trading costs, and potential discounts to net asset value (NAV) should also be considered when evaluating the long-term impact on gold investment returns.
Recent supply chain dynamics have led to fluctuating premiums on physical gold products. Investors should monitor these premiums when timing purchases, as they can significantly impact the total cost of acquisition.
High-Net-Worth Income & Spending Report
Long Angle's annual High-Net-Worth Income and Spending report analyzes income sources, expenses, savings strategies, and spending behaviors of high-net-worth households.
Diversifying Gold Investments
Given the variety of investment vehicles available, high-net-worth investors may find a balanced approach to gold allocation effective. A diversified gold strategy can mitigate the limitations of any single asset type and align more closely with the investor’s goals. For instance, a mix of physical gold and ETFs can combine security with liquidity, while mining stocks can introduce a growth component that adds upside potential.
While a straightforward allocation strategy might focus on one gold vehicle, a layered approach can maximize the utility of gold across market conditions. Some high-net-worth investors, for example, may choose to allocate 60% to physical gold for wealth preservation and 40% to ETFs for ease of liquidity. Those with higher risk tolerance might add a mining index to the mix, balancing stability with potential capital appreciation.
Some investors find success with a disciplined dollar-cost averaging approach, allocating a fixed percentage of their portfolio to gold purchases regardless of market prices. This strategy can help manage entry-point risk while building a substantial position over time.
Gold as a Strategic Asset for High-Net-Worth Investors
Gold remains a multifaceted asset class, offering benefits beyond simple portfolio diversification. High-net-worth investors should consider not only the historical performance of the asset but also the strategic role it will play within a broader wealth plan. Whether viewed as an inflation hedge, a wealth safeguard, or a growth opportunity, gold offers valuable flexibility, especially when thoughtfully allocated across different investment types.
With tax policies, economic conditions, and geopolitical dynamics constantly evolving, those investing in gold should monitor their investments regularly to ensure that their goals are being met.
High-net-worth communities, such as the one at Long Angle, provide a space for investors to discuss topics ranging from how to invest in gold to parenting advice to travel recommendations. In addition to our online community, members can participate in events (both in-person and online), peer groups, and investment opportunities. Join Long Angle to learn more.
Looking to expand your investment network?
Join Long Angle, a private community of high-net-worth investors. Together, we leverage our collective expertise and assets to access, diligence, and underwrite institutional-quality alternative investments.
